
Measure the roof surface
Floor area misses the effect of pitch, overhangs, a garage roof and dormers. A bid should say how much roof surface it covers. A roofing square equals 100 square feet. On an illustrative 1,800-square-foot roof, the measured surface is 18 squares. An illustrative material order of 20 squares would include two squares beyond that surface, about 11% extra for cuts or other ordering needs. Ask each bidder to distinguish measured area from ordered quantity and explain the allowance for your layout.
Look at the work that adds time
| Cost driver | Question to ask |
|---|---|
| Pitch and height | Which roof sections require additional staging, handling or fall protection? |
| Shape and transitions | How many valleys, walls, chimneys and skylights are in the scope, and what work is included at each? |
| Tear-off and access | How many layers are included? Can a container and material delivery reach a suitable spot? |
| The roof system | Which covering, underlayment, ventilation and edge details are priced? |
| Material discovered after tear-off | What decking is included, what is the installed unit rate and who authorizes added work? |
A chimney and several valleys can make two roofs of equal area different jobs. Ask both bidders to mark the details they will rebuild. The IBHS overview of a resilient roof shows why the roof edge and the deck can matter as much to performance as the cover itself.
Flag access and scheduling early
Tell each contractor about steep drives, narrow approaches, gutters, landscaping, shared parking and where debris could be staged. Ask whether extra handling is in the base estimate. During a cold-weather or wet-weather period, ask which conditions affect installation and how an opened roof would be protected if the crew needs to pause.
Ask for a scoped quote for your house
A price from a neighbor's job is hard to apply if the roof area, layers, materials and details differ. The FTC advises homeowners to get multiple written estimates that list the work, materials, completion information and price. If you already have a measurement or written scope, bring it to your roof replacement estimate so the contractor can explain differences clearly.

