ALL-IN-ONECONSTRUCTION USABroome County · Upstate NY

How to Compare Two Roofing Estimates, Line by Line

Start with five lines: tear-off, decking, flashing, disposal and warranty. These tell you which work is included, what can change after demolition and who handles a problem later. Put both bids side by side before you compare totals.

Illustrative estimate with tear-off, decking, flashing, disposal, and warranty lines
Illustrative estimate scope. See the complete comparison below.

Put the job in the same units

One roofer may estimate by the square and another may show only a total. A roofing square is 100 square feet of roof area. Ask how many existing layers each bid includes, what roof area was measured and what quantity of material is ordered. A material order may include extra for cuts. Keep the square footage of the roof separate from the number of squares in the order.

Request the same basic information in writing from both bidders: a description of the work, the materials, the anticipated completion date and the price. The Federal Trade Commission's home improvement guidance also recommends asking for an explanation if estimates differ widely.

An illustrative estimate you can annotate

The entries below describe a hypothetical job. Use them to mark up your own proposals.

Sample estimate lines and the questions they should answer
LineSample scopeAsk before approving
Tear-offRemove one existing shingle layer down to the roof deck.What happens if a second layer is found, and what is its unit charge?
DeckingTwo damaged panels included. Additional panels are charged at the written per-panel rate after approval.Does that rate include labor, removal and disposal? How will I see the damaged area?
FlashingReplace chimney flashing and plumbing vent boots. List other transitions separately.Which pieces are reused, which are replaced and what if siding or masonry needs work?
DisposalDebris container, hauling, disposal and final cleanup included.Where does the container go, how are paths protected and who checks for nails?
WarrantyManufacturer terms and contractor workmanship terms documented separately.Who handles a claim, what triggers coverage and are registration or maintenance required?

Read what sits between the old roof and the new shingles

Look for how the bid handles underlayment, roof edges, valleys, chimneys and penetrations. The IBHS FORTIFIED Roof guidance illustrates how the deck, edges and roof covering perform as a system. Ask each bidder to describe the details it intends to install on your home. A system name alone leaves out which details are priced.

Compare the base bid and one change scenario

Write each base total on the same sheet. Then use the same hypothetical condition for both bids, such as four damaged panels when two are included. For that bid, calculate base total plus two times its installed per-panel rate. Ask the other bidder what four panels would add to its own base. Record who authorizes added work and whether the roof can be safely protected if you need time to decide.

Take your notes into a roof replacement conversation. Ask to have the final scope, cost assumptions and warranty documents attached to the estimate before signing.

Sources

Keep reading